Change Edition

Ryanair hit for 9 million euros by French court
Economics

Ryanair hit for 9 million euros by French court

3 min. 02.10.2013 From our online archive
Irish airline Ryanair was Wednesday ordered to pay nearly nine million euros in damages and interest after being found guilty of breaching French labour law.

(AFP) - Irish airline Ryanair was Wednesday ordered to pay nearly nine million euros in damages and interest after being found guilty of breaching French labour law.

A court in southern France, which also fined the company 200,000 euros, awarded the damages after ruling that Ryanair had illegally given locally based staff Irish contracts in order to save money on payroll and other taxes.

The company was also charged with preventing workplace councils from functioning and hampering employees' access to unions.

"By refusing to submit to French legislation on social security contributions, the company set up a system of social dumping allowing it to reduce operating costs," the court said in its ruling.

Noting that social charges in France were at a rate of 40 to 45 percent, against only 10.75 percent in Ireland, the court said Ryanair had created "a situation of unfair competition vis-a-vis other airlines that respected national law."

Ryanair said in a statement that it would appeal the ruling, insisting it had acted "in full compliance with Irish and EU regulations."

If upheld on appeal, the damages will have to be paid to France's social security system, the state pension funds and unions representing airline workers, all of whom were plaintiffs in the action against Ryanair.

Airline could have faced heavier penalties

Lawyers for the plaintiffs said they were satisfied with the ruling.

"It was recognised that there was fraud," said Jean-Victor Borel, a lawyer for URSSAF, the French organisation that collects social security contributions and was awarded more than 4.5 million euros under the ruling.

The company could have faced even heavier penalties but the judge rejected a prosecution request for an additional fine equivalent to the value of four Boeing 737s that the airline had flown out of the southern French city of Marseille between 2007-11.

The case centres around a facility operated by the company at Marignane, near Marseille and Aix-en-Provence.

Ryanair based four planes and 127 employees at the site without applying French labour law or filling out tax declarations in the country.

Ryanair had argued that it did not have a permanent base in the area and that it was therefore entitled to keep its workforce on Irish contracts, in line with its interpretation of EU rules on mobile workers.

Prosecutors said this claim was not credible since the airline had established offices at the airport and its staff were living locally.

Verdict against EU rules, says Ryanair

The case echoes a similar ruling for easyJet, which in 2010 was ordered to pay more than 1.4 million euros in damages to unions representing crew for hiring 170 employees under British contracts at a Paris airport.

In its statement, Ryanair said the ruling, based on a 2006 government decree, went against European Union rules.

"Ryanair believes there is a clear contradiction between current EU employment regulations... and the 2006 French decree, which seeks to require airline crews operating in Ireland to pay social taxes and pension contributions in France, despite the fact that they have already paid them in Ireland," it said.

"Ryanair intends to pursue this appeal all the way to the European Courts," it said.

The company has accused French authorities of pursuing budget airlines in a bid to protect flagship carrier Air France, which is partially owned by the state, from competition.

Separately, Ryanair said Wednesday that annual passenger numbers had risen by two percent to 80.4 million in the year to the end of September, despite issuing a profit warning last month.

The airline had warned that annual net profits would come in at the lower end of forecasts, adding it would cut winter capacity due to intense competition and falling fares in Europe.